What Profit Figure Should I Use when Valuing a Business?

The profitability of a business can be expressed in a variety of ways. Some of the most common types of profitability include:

Net profit image

Net Profit after Tax:

This is usually seen as the bottom line profit figure in formal financial statements that have been prepared for tax and statutory reporting.

Net Profit before Tax:

This is the bottom-line figure in management accounting profit and loss statements. It also appears in statutory financial statements.

EBIT (Earnings Before Interest and Tax):​

The purpose of using EBIT is to see the profitability of the business operation, before it is obscured by tax and  the financing cost interest.

One shortcoming of EBIT is that whilst it does take depreciation into account, this depreciation has often been determined based on Tax Office rules. This means that the depreciation may not necessarily reflect the actual rates at which the business is using up its equipment and other capital assts. As a result, valuers will often need to adjust depreciation to make it more representative of the actual rates at which the business uses up its equipment and other capital assets.

EBIT (Earnings Before Interest and Tax) image
EBITDA image

EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation and Amortisation):

This form of profit shows the underlying profitability of a business before it is obscured by tax, the financing cost interest, as well the capital costs depreciation and amortisation.

A weakness of EBITDA is the fact that it does not take into account the ongoing costs associated with using up capital items, such as plant and equipment. In reality, the business will need to purchase new equipment to remain competitive, to keep up to date with changes in technology, and to replace items that have been used up.

PEBITDA (Proprietor’s Earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation and Amortisation):

This is the most common form of profitability used in the valuation of small and micro businesses. It is also frequently referred to as the Return to an Owner Operator or Owner’s Discretionary Earnings.

Small and micro businesses often have no or minimal profit on an EBIT or EBITDA basis. Despite this, there can often be good demand for these businesses, and they are frequently bought and sold in the marketplace. This is because buyers of these businesses may see the purchase as ‘buying a job’. As a result, they consider the salary and superannuation that they will be taking out of the business as profit.

Therefore, PEBITDA is effectively the EBITDA of the business plus the salary and superannuation that a full-time working owner of the business would be paid by the business.

PEBITDA image
Net Cash Flow

Net Cash Flow:

Certain valuation methods, such as the Discounted Cash Flow method, use the net cash flow of the business. When determining cash flows, the valuer not only looks at cash inflows from sales and cash outflows relating to expenses, they also look at the timing of cash outflows due to expected purchases of equipment and other capital items. In addition, the valuer looks at the impact on cash flow caused by changes in working capital needs of the business over time. Further, the valuer will generally look at cash outflows relating to tax.

Owners and directors of privately owned businesses often take a variety of perks out of their businesses. In addition, there may be family members working in the business at above or below market rates. On top of this, business owners also often own the business premises. When this is the case, the rent may not be at market rate. Business valuers need to make adjustments to reported profit to take account of these perks and non-arm’s length arrangements. Additionally, valuers may need to make adjustments, for certain one-off transactions and expected changes in the future performance of the business. Overall, it is highly likely that the valuer will not simply be using the profit figure at the bottom of your profit and loss statement.

The profit figure selected depends on the valuation method that will be used. For example, Market methods often use EBIT, EBITDA, Gross Profit and/or PEBITDA. The Capitalisation of Earnings Method usually involves the use of EBIT, EBITDA or Net Cash Fow. The Discounted Cash Flow will generally use Net Cash Flow.

Overall, it is a good idea to consult a professional business valuer, an accountant who has experience with business valuations, or a business broker to help with the valuation of your business. This should help to ensure that the correct profit figure is used and that the correct valuation method is applied for your business.